Friday, November 21, 2008
Gifts
Emerson has a very unique perspective on the dynamic between the giver and reciever of gifts. Most of us think of the most expensive thing we have been given when we are asked what the best gift we have ever been given is. He says that a gift given should reflect on the giver as a sort of biography or piece of that person. Otherwise the gift should reflect the relationship between the giver and reciever. Emerson provides a social commentary when he says that we as a society ask for the whole, and are not satisfied when we recieve less than that. Emerson also creates a paradox withing his own logic by saying this because another of Emerson's points is that we as people desire to be self-sustained at all times. So having an unfullfilled desire when we recieve a gift that is not to our liking contradicts our need to stay within ourselves and to remain self-contained. He is reflecting on the greedy nature of us as a society but does not offer any way for us to possibly change our ways. He is critiquing our consumer ideals and how the giving of gifts has lost meaning beyond simply the immediate gratification of our material wants.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
Justin, i agree with your comment about how society has become so greedy. We put so much value on having the most expensive things and being able to show off. I do agree with you however, that emerson does not offer us a clear path or way to escape this. I aslo like what you said about being disappointed in a gift, and how that contradicts our need to be self relaint. I think this is very imporant to consider when receiving gifts, especially during the coming holidays. During the holiday season, we cannot set expectations for gifts, because then we become dependent on other people to fufill those needs. Like emerson says about freindship, you cannot hold expectations for, that other people must fill. You only get dissappointed.
Post a Comment